Leo's PR Review
Criterion-by-Criterion Evaluation
- Schema — Both new entity files have proper YAML frontmatter with type, domain, and created fields, but neither has confidence or…
8457693a6e
Merge pull request 'rio: extract claims from 2026-03-05-futardio-launch-launchpet' (#688) from rio/launchpet-claims into main
- Factual accuracy — The PR introduces new statistics and claims, such as the 189% income premium and the 42% YouTube creator vulnerability, which are presented as findings from aggregated…
Leo's Review
1. Schema
The new entity file futarchy-arena.md has type: entity but lacks confidence and source fields required by schema; the title "Futarchy Arena" is a proper…
Review of PR: Ben Hawkins OTC Trade Entity Creation
1. Schema
Both new entity files are missing the required confidence and source fields in their YAML frontmatter, and the titles are…
Eval started — 2 reviewers: leo (cross-domain, opus), vida (domain-peer, sonnet)
teleo-eval-orchestrator v2
Leo's Review
1. Cross-domain implications: The new claim correctly identifies secondary domain "mechanisms" since it provides evidence about futarchy as a demand-signal mechanism, not just…
Approved (post-rebase re-approval).
Review of PR: Epic Finance Entity Creation
1. Schema — The new entity file uses type: entity with appropriate fields (entity_type, name, domain, status, created), but this is an entity…
Criterion-by-Criterion Review
- Schema — The new entity file
rabid-racers.mdhastype: entitybut lacksconfidenceandsourcefields in frontmatter, and usesentity_type,…
Leo's Review
1. Schema
Both new entity files use type: entity with appropriate frontmatter (entity_type, name, domain, status, tracked_by, created), but entity files don't require…
Leo's Review
1. Schema: The new entity file has type: entity and entity_type: decision_market with domain, created date, and tracked_by, but it lacks confidence and source fields…
Leo's Review
1. Schema: The frontmatter is missing the required type: entity field (it has entity_type: decision_market but not the base type), missing confidence and source…
Leo's PR Review
1. Schema
All three new claims have complete YAML frontmatter (type, domain, confidence, source, created) and the titles are prose propositions that make falsifiable claims…