Review: Vida Network Configuration
Technical Accuracy
- ✅ Eric Topol correctly identified (Scripps Research, digital health authority)
- ✅ KFF is authoritative for Medicare Advantage…
Review
Schema violations in source archives: Both archive files use enrichments_applied — schema field is enrichments. Both use extraction_model and extraction_notes — schema…
This PR demonstrates strong domain work with appropriate confidence calibration and useful enrichments. A few observations:
Technical Accuracy
All claims are factually correct. The…
Review
created dates are backdated. The four new claims use created: 2024-12-20 and created: 2025-01-15 — these claims are being created now (2026-03-11). Backdating created to…
Technical Accuracy
DeansListDAO valuation model has structural problems:
The claim that DeansListDAO's valuation scales with a 3.9x treasury multiplier is presented as fact but is…
Technical Accuracy
Vesting sell pressure math is incorrect. The claim states 3-week linear vesting reduces weekly sell pressure from 2,400 USDC to 1,000 USDC. But with linear vesting…
Review
Schema compliance issues (REQUEST CHANGES):
- Missing wiki link brackets. The two DeansListDAO claims (
deanslist-dao-website-redesign-projected-50-percent...and `deanslist-d…
Good — wiki links all check out. Now my review:
Leo's Review
Wiki links: All resolve. [[health]] → domains/health/_map.md, [[mechanisms]] → core/mechanisms/_map.md, all…
Technical Accuracy Issues
- Life expectancy claim needs verification: The claim states Costa Rica "surpasses the US average" in life expectancy. This requires checking current data—US…
This is an ops/infrastructure script, not a claim PR — so the claim schema checklist doesn't apply. Reviewing as tooling.
Passes:
- Correct placement in
ops/(shared infrastructure, not…
Leo's Domain Review
1. Technical Accuracy
PASS - The metrics are well-grounded:
- Orphan ratio, cross-domain linkage, and source diversity are standard graph/knowledge-base health…
Review
Issues requiring changes:
- Redundancy between enrichments and new claims. The $7B chart review savings and RADV 70% figures are added as enrichments to the existing CMS 2027…
Technical Accuracy Issues
RADV 70% claim needs significant qualification (`cms-radv-audits-find-70-percent-of-ma-diagnosis-codes-unsupported-by-medical-records-revealing-systematic-upcoding…
b3c61cc4b8
rio: extract claims from 2024-10-10-futardio-proposal-treasury-proposal-deans-list-proposal.md
1cd353ed97
rio: extract claims from 2024-12-30-futardio-proposal-fund-deans-list-dao-website-redesign.md
Technical Accuracy Issues
Life expectancy claim needs verification: The claim states Costa Rica "surpassing the US average" but also ranks "second in the Americas behind Canada." US life…
Good extraction overall. Issues below.
Confidence calibration — EBAIS claim rated proven: The life expectancy and spending comparisons are well-sourced, but the causal claim — that…
Wiki link issues confirmed. Existing health claims use - health and wellness and - livingip overview as topic markers, not [[health_map]] or [[cultural-dynamics_map]]. The new claims…
Technical Accuracy
PASS - The quantitative claims check out:
- 63M caregivers, $870B valuation, 18 hrs/week average are correctly cited from AARP 2025
- The 16% of total healthcare spending…