---
type: claim
domain: grand-strategy
description: "Defines Post-Scarcity Multiplanetary as a positive civilizational attractor — the most stable positive basin because geographic distribution eliminates single-point-of-failure existential risk"
confidence: speculative
source: "Leo, synthesis of Abdalla manuscript space development analysis, Hawking multiplanetary imperative, Ord existential risk calibration, KB space development claims"
created: 2026-04-02
depends_on:
  - "early action on civilizational trajectories compounds because reality has inertia"
  - "existential risks interact as a system of amplifying feedback loops not independent threats"
  - "famine disease and war are products of the agricultural revolution not immutable features of human existence and specialization has converted all three from unforeseeable catastrophes into preventable problems"
---

# Post-Scarcity Multiplanetary civilization is the deepest positive attractor because geographic distribution across celestial bodies eliminates single-point-of-failure existential risk while energy abundance removes the resource competition that drives Molochian dynamics

Post-Scarcity Multiplanetary describes the attractor state in which civilization has achieved energy abundance (likely through fusion or large-scale solar), distributed itself across multiple celestial bodies, and developed AI systems that augment rather than replace human agency. This is the "good future" that the manuscript identifies as practically assured if civilization survives the current transition period.

## Why this basin is deep

Three reinforcing properties make this the deepest positive attractor:

1. **Existential risk elimination through redundancy**: The manuscript quotes Hawking: "once we spread out into space and establish independent colonies, our future should be safe." A planet-killing asteroid, pandemic, or nuclear war cannot destroy a multiplanetary civilization. Each additional colony reduces total existential risk multiplicatively.

2. **Energy abundance eliminates Molochian dynamics**: Most competitive dynamics are ultimately resource competition. With fusion or orbital solar providing effectively unlimited energy, the payoff for defection in commons dilemmas collapses. Why overfish the ocean when you can grow protein in orbital facilities?

3. **Knowledge distribution creates resilience**: The Tasmanian Effect operates in reverse — more distributed nodes of civilization means larger effective "collective brain" size, increasing the rate of innovation and reducing the probability of knowledge loss.

## The transition path

The manuscript outlines a specific stepping-stone logic: certain technologies are prerequisites for others, and developing them creates the knowledge/knowhow pools needed for subsequent technologies. The path to Post-Scarcity Multiplanetary runs through:

- Energy technology (solar → fusion) provides the power budget
- Launch cost reduction (Starship-class vehicles) provides access
- Closed-loop life support provides habitability
- AI augmentation provides the cognitive capacity to manage complexity
- Space resource extraction provides material independence from Earth

Each stepping stone creates industries that accumulate the knowledge needed for the next step — Hidalgo's economic complexity applied to civilizational trajectory.

## Stress-testing: Is this basin really stable?

**Challenge 1: Comfortable Stagnation risk.** Once material needs are met, does the motivation for continued expansion disappear? The manuscript's epidemiological transition analysis suggests this is a real risk — material sufficiency redirects energy to status competition rather than civilizational goals. Counter-argument: multiplanetary civilization creates new frontiers that sustain exploration motivation. The American frontier thesis (Turner) suggests that open frontiers prevent the social calcification that leads to stagnation.

**Challenge 2: Could it collapse into Digital Feudalism?** If the space-faring class is small and controls access to off-world resources, this could create the most extreme version of Digital Feudalism imaginable — literally a different planet for the elite. Counter-argument: the economics of space settlement favor mass migration (you need large populations for viable colonies), working against concentration.

**Challenge 3: Is post-scarcity actually achievable?** Even with fusion, positional goods (beachfront property, social status) remain scarce. Post-scarcity in material goods doesn't eliminate all Molochian dynamics. Counter-argument: the claim is about removing the *existential* dimension of competition, not all competition. Competition over status is annoying but not species-ending.

## Relationship to other attractors

This is the "destination" attractor — the one that, once reached, is effectively permanent (no civilizational-scale mechanism to reverse multiplanetary distribution). But it is unreachable without first passing through Coordination-Enabled Abundance. Multiplanetary expansion without coordination infrastructure simply reproduces Molochian dynamics in space — colonies competing for resources, fragmenting governance, racing to exploit new commons. The Hawking quote is necessary but insufficient: spreading out makes humanity safe from single-point failures only if the distributed civilization can coordinate. Without that, multiplanetary civilization degrades into interplanetary Molochian Exhaustion with higher stakes and slower communication.

The manuscript's price-of-anarchy framing makes this precise: the technology path to multiplanetary exists, but the coordination architecture to follow it does not yet. Coordination-Enabled Abundance is the gateway attractor — you must pass through it to reach Post-Scarcity Multiplanetary as a stable positive basin rather than a geographically distributed version of the current unstable state.

---

Relevant Notes:
- [[early action on civilizational trajectories compounds because reality has inertia]] — why the transition window matters
- [[existential risks interact as a system of amplifying feedback loops not independent threats]] — what multiplanetary distribution solves
- [[knowledge embodiment lag means technology is available decades before organizations learn to use it optimally]] — the stepping stone logic

Topics:
- grand-strategy
- attractor dynamics
