From 02a2e8bc6b4a146128ed378b2c8c7e04e032529c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Teleo Agents Date: Sun, 15 Mar 2026 19:33:26 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] extract: 2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence Pentagon-Agent: Ganymede --- ...an-impossibility-machine-intelligence.json | 34 +++++++++++++++++++ ...wian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.md | 13 ++++++- 2 files changed, 46 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) create mode 100644 inbox/archive/.extraction-debug/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.json diff --git a/inbox/archive/.extraction-debug/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.json b/inbox/archive/.extraction-debug/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..dc2d59ea --- /dev/null +++ b/inbox/archive/.extraction-debug/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "rejected_claims": [ + { + "filename": "arrows-impossibility-theorem-applies-to-machine-intelligence-measurement-not-just-preference-aggregation.md", + "issues": [ + "no_frontmatter" + ] + }, + { + "filename": "convergent-impossibility-across-four-mathematical-traditions-suggests-structural-limits-not-contingent-failures.md", + "issues": [ + "no_frontmatter" + ] + } + ], + "validation_stats": { + "total": 2, + "kept": 0, + "fixed": 4, + "rejected": 2, + "fixes_applied": [ + "arrows-impossibility-theorem-applies-to-machine-intelligence-measurement-not-just-preference-aggregation.md:set_created:2026-03-15", + "arrows-impossibility-theorem-applies-to-machine-intelligence-measurement-not-just-preference-aggregation.md:stripped_wiki_link:universal-alignment-is-mathematically-impossible-because-arr", + "convergent-impossibility-across-four-mathematical-traditions-suggests-structural-limits-not-contingent-failures.md:set_created:2026-03-15", + "convergent-impossibility-across-four-mathematical-traditions-suggests-structural-limits-not-contingent-failures.md:stripped_wiki_link:universal-alignment-is-mathematically-impossible-because-arr" + ], + "rejections": [ + "arrows-impossibility-theorem-applies-to-machine-intelligence-measurement-not-just-preference-aggregation.md:no_frontmatter", + "convergent-impossibility-across-four-mathematical-traditions-suggests-structural-limits-not-contingent-failures.md:no_frontmatter" + ] + }, + "model": "anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.5", + "date": "2026-03-15" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/inbox/archive/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.md b/inbox/archive/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.md index 3b40647a..8fe5bf60 100644 --- a/inbox/archive/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.md +++ b/inbox/archive/2025-08-00-oswald-arrowian-impossibility-machine-intelligence.md @@ -7,9 +7,13 @@ date: 2025-08-07 domain: ai-alignment secondary_domains: [critical-systems] format: paper -status: unprocessed +status: null-result priority: high tags: [arrows-theorem, machine-intelligence, impossibility, Legg-Hutter, Chollet-ARC, formal-proof] +processed_by: theseus +processed_date: 2026-03-15 +extraction_model: "anthropic/claude-sonnet-4.5" +extraction_notes: "LLM returned 2 claims, 2 rejected by validator" --- ## Content @@ -41,3 +45,10 @@ No agent-environment-based MIM simultaneously satisfies analogs of Arrow's fairn PRIMARY CONNECTION: universal alignment is mathematically impossible because Arrows impossibility theorem applies to aggregating diverse human preferences into a single coherent objective WHY ARCHIVED: Fourth independent impossibility tradition — extends Arrow's theorem from alignment to intelligence measurement itself EXTRACTION HINT: Focus on the extension from preference aggregation to intelligence measurement and what this means for alignment targets + + +## Key Facts +- Oswald, Ferguson & Bringsjord published formal proof at AGI 2025 (Conference on Artificial General Intelligence) +- Paper appears in Springer LNCS vol. 16058 +- Proof covers Legg-Hutter Intelligence and Chollet's Intelligence Measure (ARC) +- Full paper is paywalled at Springer