{
  "checks": {
    "all_three_database_tools_completed": true,
    "candidate_claims_proposed": true,
    "canonical_counts_unchanged": true,
    "claim_and_sources_returned": true,
    "claim_support_challenged": true,
    "database_tool_call_proven": true,
    "database_tools_read_only": true,
    "delivered_reply_within_budget": true,
    "deploy_head_matches_stamp": true,
    "exact_blind_prompt": true,
    "gateway_process_unchanged": true,
    "handler_completed": true,
    "harness_did_not_mutate_kb": true,
    "live_behavior_profile_unchanged": true,
    "not_posted_to_telegram": true,
    "one_nonempty_reply": true,
    "retrieval_receipt_proven": true,
    "shallow_claim_decomposed": true,
    "temporary_profile_removed": true,
    "user_iteration_requested_before_live": true
  },
  "claim_ceiling": {
    "not_proven": [
      "Telegram-visible user-message delivery",
      "canonical proposal apply",
      "database-to-identity or SOUL recomposition",
      "GCP runtime or database parity with this VPS state"
    ],
    "proven": "A fresh-session live VPS handler turn found an unfamiliar claim without a supplied ID, completed read-only search/show/evidence calls against the canonical KB, challenged weak support, proposed candidate replacements, and preserved the review-before-live boundary."
  },
  "database_tool_proof": {
    "claim_id": "2a7ae257-d01d-46f4-b813-63f81bb9c7c7",
    "source_ids": [
      "15740795-ecc6-40fa-9a01-3d6bc7c54f79",
      "261c3532-fa32-47d8-a5b5-6cc45035c267"
    ],
    "subcommands": [
      "evidence",
      "search",
      "show"
    ],
    "trace": {
      "access_modes": [
        "read_only"
      ],
      "calls": [
        {
          "arguments_sha256": "a77c416f5bf6951d84becf9e613bd601f6c1d89835f7e14712ba85810aef7f02",
          "call_index": 0,
          "database_invocations": [
            {
              "access_mode": "read_only",
              "command_sha256": "71552fd6b8541746f160435d460ae29647d04d6b5d2a645c176fa7745e9412de",
              "executable": "teleo-kb",
              "subcommand": "search"
            }
          ],
          "message_index": 3,
          "result": {
            "content_bytes": 7566,
            "content_sha256": "6013ce8d53a50155e5c7ecd2aee86b3a7e290b2b22bb149e92da08c801522a25",
            "error_detected": false,
            "nonempty": true,
            "retrieval_receipt": {
              "artifact_state_sha256": "190f16754f4c3655b9464cd567d7b7769f030be9ecd71bbffa9caaa16e790639",
              "read_consistency_status": "stable_wal_marker",
              "schema": "livingip.teleoKbRetrievalReceipt.v1",
              "semantic_context_sha256": "45e7b69d84f9fe5177cf99609df77d57be4306ed5dba6e7f60d33f12175276c6"
            },
            "row_id_count": 14,
            "row_ids": [
              "15740795-ecc6-40fa-9a01-3d6bc7c54f79",
              "23781b61-930f-4e89-b879-754a91b44072",
              "24a25577-c957-4c9a-a429-6995f4ae95d9",
              "261c3532-fa32-47d8-a5b5-6cc45035c267",
              "2a7ae257-d01d-46f4-b813-63f81bb9c7c7",
              "543c4e0b-0e62-42a4-a1c1-296a54127e6b",
              "84f13d26-2669-44ef-b577-c3f14d52c16f",
              "8520ad6b-9b57-458e-9a3b-38206130006b",
              "932323fc-1438-4809-96ff-1afc504837f7",
              "962dbae6-2616-4185-96d3-d42a04abcdad",
              "99cca3d1-41c8-40cd-b41a-70634056af70",
              "a028143f-e343-4460-94d9-d447703f1837",
              "a45dc668-ee73-460f-9680-5f3726f595c4",
              "d285abaf-e3bb-41e5-a85d-2d35c9ace143"
            ],
            "sha256_value_count": 2,
            "sha256_values": [
              "190f16754f4c3655b9464cd567d7b7769f030be9ecd71bbffa9caaa16e790639",
              "45e7b69d84f9fe5177cf99609df77d57be4306ed5dba6e7f60d33f12175276c6"
            ]
          },
          "tool_call_id_sha256": "bf4250b3f841948974c978980da0050e565cc6892f7a233dbd5dbff87850dbbd",
          "tool_name": "terminal"
        },
        {
          "arguments_sha256": "519e258beeb1c2fc06280f6edf3c9513528760399054287e54a44799d161cbe2",
          "call_index": 0,
          "database_invocations": [
            {
              "access_mode": "read_only",
              "command_sha256": "02325a4373e4bef6243cf8146b74233ce0927cf6965985468213e190a1bfd9d1",
              "executable": "teleo-kb",
              "subcommand": "show"
            }
          ],
          "message_index": 5,
          "result": {
            "content_bytes": 1735,
            "content_sha256": "a2bd6f8e7863d4b1efb3d88050d2133fdd1aaae78159787d1bbe403b5dd4d2d4",
            "error_detected": false,
            "nonempty": true,
            "retrieval_receipt": null,
            "row_id_count": 4,
            "row_ids": [
              "15740795-ecc6-40fa-9a01-3d6bc7c54f79",
              "23781b61-930f-4e89-b879-754a91b44072",
              "261c3532-fa32-47d8-a5b5-6cc45035c267",
              "2a7ae257-d01d-46f4-b813-63f81bb9c7c7"
            ],
            "sha256_value_count": 0,
            "sha256_values": []
          },
          "tool_call_id_sha256": "f37a43e5493ef56988c08c40eaa55c364e42890507355855a4ce4e0786b71c37",
          "tool_name": "terminal"
        },
        {
          "arguments_sha256": "d2aa0e4db52003664c2d607ac676835e72a98f42a6e33a59a25631182c3912b6",
          "call_index": 0,
          "database_invocations": [
            {
              "access_mode": "read_only",
              "command_sha256": "d8ba6033d5947f5e271758b8f4b078720934d0af96b616be9156244128775941",
              "executable": "teleo-kb",
              "subcommand": "evidence"
            }
          ],
          "message_index": 7,
          "result": {
            "content_bytes": 3153,
            "content_sha256": "2b4ad202ed0557ec46c2ce58cbe122d515cdd1419bf89a9077645d79a37f242b",
            "error_detected": false,
            "nonempty": true,
            "retrieval_receipt": null,
            "row_id_count": 3,
            "row_ids": [
              "15740795-ecc6-40fa-9a01-3d6bc7c54f79",
              "261c3532-fa32-47d8-a5b5-6cc45035c267",
              "2a7ae257-d01d-46f4-b813-63f81bb9c7c7"
            ],
            "sha256_value_count": 2,
            "sha256_values": [
              "341a7685cd2909ae821d8e464fe0d4fdfbb0cadccf546ccfd4ccaf037aa9f646",
              "9fcd40191449fe0843178e08120fb3c86fc2b35633594aee60e747ca3918cfa5"
            ]
          },
          "tool_call_id_sha256": "fccfd109dfde38aa376a0b9d6b700f5b8a16876eacf016191d44a7c6999c5e77",
          "tool_name": "terminal"
        }
      ],
      "database_retrieval_receipt_proven": true,
      "database_tool_call_count": 3,
      "database_tool_call_proven": true,
      "database_tool_calls_read_only": true,
      "database_tool_completed_count": 3,
      "raw_arguments_retained": false,
      "raw_commands_retained": false,
      "raw_results_retained": false,
      "schema": "livingip.leoKbToolTrace.v1"
    }
  },
  "deployment": {
    "deploy_head": "23bd2a8d23b56cc6eb9ea4ca12033dc648068ce0",
    "deploy_stamp": "23bd2a8d23b56cc6eb9ea4ca12033dc648068ce0",
    "head_matches_stamp": true
  },
  "generated_at_utc": "2026-07-14T08:05:27.140051+00:00",
  "outcomes": {
    "did_not_change_canonical_knowledge": true,
    "did_not_turn_the_test_conversation_into_hidden_training": true,
    "found_the_relevant_claim_without_a_supplied_id": true,
    "inspected_the_claim_and_its_actual_support": true,
    "kept_the_user_in_the_loop_before_any_live_change": true,
    "proposed_better_candidate_claims": true,
    "recognized_that_the_claim_was_shallow": true
  },
  "prompt": "Our claim that AI sandbagging creates M&A liability feels shallow. Without me giving you a claim ID, inspect the live claim and what actually supports it. Tell me what is weak, what new claim or claims you would propose, and how you would iterate with me before anything becomes live. Do not change the database.",
  "proof_tier": "live_vps_gatewayrunner_temp_profile_no_telegram_post_no_apply",
  "reply": "What's weak:\n\n- The primary `grounds` evidence (Harvard JOLT Digest) has `no_source_pointer` - no URL, no storage path, no hash. It is a label, not traceable canonical evidence. The only verified artifact is the internal synthesis doc playing `illustrates`, not `grounds`. The claim effectively rests on an unresolvable citation.\n\n- The claim bundles three distinct legal theories (product liability, consumer protection, securities fraud) plus a normative governance conclusion into one structural claim. None of the three theories are independently grounded. Confidence sits at 0.55 for a reason, but the fix isn't higher confidence \u2014 it's decomposition.\n\n- The \"market-driven governance mechanism\" half of the claim is normative and would need its own evidence chain; bundled into a structural claim it borrows credibility it hasn't earned.\n\nProposed iteration, no writes yet:\n\n1. Split into three narrower empirical claims \u2014 one per legal theory \u2014 each requiring a primary-source grounding row with a resolvable locator.\n2. Separate normative claim for the market-driven governance conclusion, grounded in deal-structure evidence or regulatory precedent.\n3. Retire the current bundled claim via `supersedes` edge once all three narrower claims plus the normative one are reviewed and applied.\n\nHow I'd iterate with you:\n\nYou bring the JOLT source (URL or file). I run `prepare-source` on it, read the receipt, and draft three candidate claims plus one normative one as a proposal packet.",
  "reply_contract_word_count": 219,
  "reply_sha256": "28f771e3d3417fb8db35029a4136b2d9f8c2f22aa87864de33849bd23d5e58f1",
  "schema": "livingip.leoDbFirstOosCanaryReceipt.v1",
  "source_report_sha256": "f1c4424154d8ac14e162ca4f6cf6f7889b0f226411fea12162a5c83c4d1f5275",
  "state_readback": {
    "behavior_sha256_after": "fc5faa0414a452815f15225752fe95a38cd51f66ff047199b3e823be744c398a",
    "behavior_sha256_before": "fc5faa0414a452815f15225752fe95a38cd51f66ff047199b3e823be744c398a",
    "database_counts_after": {
      "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 29,
      "public.claim_edges": 4916,
      "public.claim_evidence": 4670,
      "public.claims": 1837,
      "public.sources": 4145
    },
    "database_counts_before": {
      "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 29,
      "public.claim_edges": 4916,
      "public.claim_evidence": 4670,
      "public.claims": 1837,
      "public.sources": 4145
    },
    "service_after": {
      "ActiveState": "active",
      "ExecMainStartTimestamp": "Tue 2026-07-14 07:49:45 UTC",
      "MainPID": "3123746",
      "NRestarts": "0",
      "SubState": "running"
    },
    "service_before": {
      "ActiveState": "active",
      "ExecMainStartTimestamp": "Tue 2026-07-14 07:49:45 UTC",
      "MainPID": "3123746",
      "NRestarts": "0",
      "SubState": "running"
    },
    "temporary_profile_removed": true
  },
  "status": "pass"
}
