{
  "applied_rollback_receipt": {
    "applied_row_keys": {
      "claim_edges": [
        "3ff15dc5-f9e8-5079-8e70-dc51d6f3e4c8"
      ],
      "claim_evidence": [
        "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb|bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd|grounds",
        "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95|7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf|illustrates"
      ],
      "claims": [
        "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
        "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95"
      ],
      "reasoning_tools": [
        "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
        "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd"
      ]
    },
    "applied_row_sha256": {
      "claim_edges": [
        "65e5186be950498bd8ff8ef2043804181ec5bef02c9c1bb36a965dd9410e8b5b"
      ],
      "claim_evidence": [
        "9164b7c63641e5cbf5422f50299490053d547ba6ce1108c970b1ebfb89dc8e25",
        "c098ddaadc9b7d14e3f0d48f844b88750fc7529813a20762240557abcdb1391b"
      ],
      "claims": [
        "e8cb8a99124bcc1f98fb0316132155c4db6d9dd12879f40a0ece82cc97e54085",
        "4ffd395e8534ab7c9d565147667c8e207eacf70dbfcae6e8959e9b9203e4429f"
      ],
      "reasoning_tools": [
        "355dee4df27c89809daa214fde69fdfb9f15fc2a29f3985582fe69d7bd797598"
      ],
      "sources": [
        "cea718e74eb3d2c2672491e2e6fc523c4c4a4ae3060babbb24652f8004a2c7fd",
        "d31a88fff760ed8d5985a2557f20524a372a0ea94893b7ad1aa1d24e6fe58050"
      ]
    },
    "apply_payload_sha256": "89faf1f2fc9481574934de0eefb91cb8056e10784ec0f966c621621ff4f91b02",
    "apply_receipt_sha256": "456247af33d4222f76c47c0a4e9228135d7a46c2c04c0f9c928b6bae5f30cde8",
    "apply_sql_sha256": "5e93caad9e259d34b2ed02f98825a41b48cff4cfe0678d60a43ed1d08298ce7a",
    "approval_snapshot_sha256": "ae28ff3694a19603b562f3233772ea68371702f22732026c75c33af944428dab",
    "artifact": "proposal_apply_lifecycle_receipt",
    "checks": {
      "apply_receipt_replay_ready": true,
      "apply_rows_have_exact_ids": true,
      "fresh_owned_preflight_consumed_by_apply": true,
      "fresh_owned_targets": true,
      "immutable_approval_unchanged": true,
      "rollback_counts_restored": true,
      "rollback_ledger_quarantined_from_worker": true,
      "rollback_replay_refused_without_mutation": true,
      "rollback_sql_exact_for_bound_rows": true,
      "rollback_target_rows_absent": true,
      "unrelated_rows_unchanged": true
    },
    "current_tier": "T2_runtime",
    "fresh_owned_apply_sql_sha256": "5e93caad9e259d34b2ed02f98825a41b48cff4cfe0678d60a43ed1d08298ce7a",
    "fresh_preflight_artifact_sha256": "33ae0ebf83cb0d29c0f07e45587b912f7716faa7360ec585c46b65e593723dee",
    "fresh_preflight_sha256": "3c4a6b90e6cbb7aa9f93966465f26ada386c2e3bd8326a8bfb23c2efb0c142b8",
    "generated_at_utc": "2026-07-15T03:30:13.458916+00:00",
    "lifecycle_receipt_sha256": "6a94df2a04b9b71f931d23d5e5fba3aa295395f9ef636f490bcffdd43d1af697",
    "pass": true,
    "production_apply_authorization_present": false,
    "production_apply_executed": false,
    "proposal_before_apply": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "proposal_payload_sha256": "3e499f82baa1fa80dba0fdeee7133dfec9c92f111a9cd1aa0b77fe0a3c12c112",
    "required_tier": "T2_runtime",
    "rollback": {
      "counts_after_rollback": {
        "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 1,
        "public.claim_edges": 0,
        "public.claim_evidence": 1,
        "public.claims": 1,
        "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
        "public.sources": 1
      },
      "counts_before_apply": {
        "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 1,
        "public.claim_edges": 0,
        "public.claim_evidence": 1,
        "public.claims": 1,
        "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
        "public.sources": 1
      },
      "delete_order": [
        "claim_evidence",
        "claim_edges",
        "reasoning_tools",
        "sources",
        "claims"
      ],
      "proposal_after": {
        "applied_at": null,
        "applied_by_agent_id": null,
        "applied_by_handle": null,
        "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
        "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
        "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
        "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
        "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
        "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
        "status": "canceled"
      },
      "rollback_sql_sha256": "5b184fc6a65373549b257c3dd40abac91bb90bd4c75b890798fcabc4174dee7b",
      "schema": "livingip.proposalApplyRollback.v2",
      "target_rows_after": {
        "claim_edges": [],
        "claim_evidence": [],
        "claims": [],
        "reasoning_tools": [],
        "sources": []
      }
    },
    "schema": "livingip.proposalApplyLifecycleReceipt.v2",
    "strongest_claim_allowed": "deterministic disposable-clone apply and compensating rollback"
  },
  "apply_transition": {
    "applied_readback": {
      "applied_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:10.578016+00",
      "applied_by_agent_id": "44444444-4444-4444-4444-444444444444",
      "applied_by_handle": "kb-apply",
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "applied"
    },
    "approved_readback": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "exact_transition": true,
    "immutable_approval_matches_applied_ledger": true,
    "immutable_approval_readback": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    }
  },
  "checks": {
    "apply_transition_exact": true,
    "claim_evidence_exact_after_permission_probe": true,
    "clone_apply_table_deltas_exact": true,
    "clone_cleanup_complete": true,
    "clone_prerequisites_omit_cluster_role_ddl": true,
    "compensating_rollback_receipt_passes": true,
    "conflict_review_separate_and_exact": true,
    "conflict_transaction_rolled_back_exactly": true,
    "first_apply_succeeded": true,
    "fresh_owned_preflight_exact": true,
    "gateway_process_unchanged": true,
    "idempotent_replay_refused": true,
    "intervening_exact_row_refused_without_adoption": true,
    "kb_apply_cannot_mutate_immutable_approval": true,
    "kb_apply_cannot_mutate_proposal_approval": true,
    "kb_apply_cannot_mutate_proposal_payload": true,
    "kb_apply_cannot_update_existing_claim_evidence": true,
    "kb_review_approval_succeeded": true,
    "kb_review_used_security_definer": true,
    "mutation_between_build_and_execute_refused": true,
    "outer_container_absent_independent_readback": true,
    "outer_container_has_no_docker_volumes": true,
    "outer_container_lifecycle_labeled": true,
    "outer_container_network_disabled": true,
    "outer_isolation_complete": true,
    "outer_labeled_container_absent_independent_readback": true,
    "outer_live_counts_exactly_unchanged": true,
    "outer_live_table_deltas_exactly_zero": true,
    "outer_service_observed_if_required": true,
    "outer_service_stable_if_observed": true,
    "outer_source_tier_enforced": true,
    "outer_workdir_absent_independent_readback": true,
    "payload_agents_seeded_exactly": true,
    "payload_projection_exact": true,
    "post_rollback_worker_reapply_refused": true,
    "proposal_exact_after_permission_probes": true,
    "review_transition_exact": true,
    "reviewer_agent_seeded_exactly": true,
    "rollback_refuses_downstream_dependencies_without_deletion": true,
    "rollback_replay_refused_without_mutation": true,
    "security_definer_dependencies_ready": true,
    "source_binding_independently_verified": true,
    "source_cluster_roles_preexisting": true,
    "source_cluster_roles_unchanged": true,
    "source_files_unchanged_during_run": true,
    "source_hash_conflict_refused": true,
    "source_table_deltas_exactly_zero": true,
    "source_target_rows_unchanged": true,
    "stale_ephemeral_paths_absent": true
  },
  "cleanup_readback": {
    "drop_attempted": true,
    "leftover_clone_database_count": 0,
    "returncode": 0,
    "stderr": "",
    "stdout": "pg_terminate_backend \n----------------------\n(0 rows)\n\nDROP DATABASE"
  },
  "cleanup_returncode": 0,
  "clone_apply_table_deltas": {
    "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
    "public.claim_edges": 1,
    "public.claim_evidence": 2,
    "public.claims": 2,
    "public.reasoning_tools": 1,
    "public.sources": 2
  },
  "clone_counts_after_apply": {
    "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 1,
    "public.claim_edges": 1,
    "public.claim_evidence": 3,
    "public.claims": 3,
    "public.reasoning_tools": 1,
    "public.sources": 3
  },
  "clone_counts_before_apply": {
    "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 1,
    "public.claim_edges": 0,
    "public.claim_evidence": 1,
    "public.claims": 1,
    "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
    "public.sources": 1
  },
  "clone_created": true,
  "clone_database": "teleo_approve_claim_isolated_4d6107db5d",
  "clone_dropped": true,
  "clone_prerequisite_sanitization": {
    "clone_sql_sha256": "a02a03a704954058745d8cee4d25597bb8eaeee2ae211d4f9be4fe055f3d98ec",
    "cluster_role_ddl_removed": true,
    "removed_alter_role_statements": 3,
    "removed_create_role_statements": 2,
    "source_sha256": "bdf8c5da05eed10665b05ad1e331e3c9c8d72464c59889a3cf8f34ab23822faa"
  },
  "conflict_apply": {
    "returncode": 1,
    "source_hash_collision_refusal": true,
    "stderr": "psql failed (3)\nSTDOUT:\n\n\nSTDERR:\nERROR:  approve_claim: source hash collision for source 4d393879-78d4-59e1-a41a-498c5fa8e1cb\nCONTEXT:  PL/pgSQL function inline_code_block line 6 at RAISE"
  },
  "conflict_readback": {
    "canonical_rows": {
      "claim_edges": [],
      "claim_evidence": [],
      "claims": [],
      "reasoning_tools": [],
      "sources": []
    },
    "canonical_rows_absent": true,
    "immutable_approval": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.5,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "3025315d-fca3-55f7-99f3-95d5588fddb4",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "conflict-canary"
              ],
              "text": "This row must roll back with the conflicting source.",
              "type": "structural"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [],
          "evidence": [],
          "reasoning_tools": [],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Conflicting source id.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-permission-probe-1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
              "id": "4d393879-78d4-59e1-a41a-498c5fa8e1cb",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "3e80ebda-c58d-5d4a-aaba-c2140371c1f4",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:14.021982+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "immutable_approval_unchanged": true,
    "proposal": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "3e80ebda-c58d-5d4a-aaba-c2140371c1f4",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.5,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "3025315d-fca3-55f7-99f3-95d5588fddb4",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "conflict-canary"
              ],
              "text": "This row must roll back with the conflicting source.",
              "type": "structural"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [],
          "evidence": [],
          "reasoning_tools": [],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Conflicting source id.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-permission-probe-1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
              "id": "4d393879-78d4-59e1-a41a-498c5fa8e1cb",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:14.021982+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-conflict-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "proposal_approval_unchanged": true
  },
  "conflict_review_transition": {
    "approved_readback": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "3e80ebda-c58d-5d4a-aaba-c2140371c1f4",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.5,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "3025315d-fca3-55f7-99f3-95d5588fddb4",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "conflict-canary"
              ],
              "text": "This row must roll back with the conflicting source.",
              "type": "structural"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [],
          "evidence": [],
          "reasoning_tools": [],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Conflicting source id.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-permission-probe-1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
              "id": "4d393879-78d4-59e1-a41a-498c5fa8e1cb",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:14.021982+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-conflict-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "exact_transition": true,
    "immutable_approval_matches_ledger": true,
    "immutable_approval_readback": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.5,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "3025315d-fca3-55f7-99f3-95d5588fddb4",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "conflict-canary"
              ],
              "text": "This row must roll back with the conflicting source.",
              "type": "structural"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [],
          "evidence": [],
          "reasoning_tools": [],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Conflicting source id.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-permission-probe-1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
              "id": "4d393879-78d4-59e1-a41a-498c5fa8e1cb",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "3e80ebda-c58d-5d4a-aaba-c2140371c1f4",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:14.021982+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "pending_immutable_approval": null,
    "pending_readback": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "3e80ebda-c58d-5d4a-aaba-c2140371c1f4",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.5,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "3025315d-fca3-55f7-99f3-95d5588fddb4",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "conflict-canary"
              ],
              "text": "This row must roll back with the conflicting source.",
              "type": "structural"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [],
          "evidence": [],
          "reasoning_tools": [],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Conflicting source id.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-permission-probe-1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
              "id": "4d393879-78d4-59e1-a41a-498c5fa8e1cb",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": null,
      "reviewed_at": null,
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": null,
      "reviewed_by_handle": null,
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-conflict-canary",
      "status": "pending_review"
    },
    "review_apply": {
      "returncode": 0,
      "stderr": "",
      "stdout": "{\"id\": \"3e80ebda-c58d-5d4a-aaba-c2140371c1f4\", \"proposal_type\": \"approve_claim\", \"review_note\": \"Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.\", \"reviewed_at\": \"2026-07-15 03:30:14.021982+00\", \"reviewed_by_agent_id\": \"99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999\", \"reviewed_by_db_role\": \"kb_review\", \"reviewed_by_handle\": \"m3ta\", \"status\": \"approved\"}"
    }
  },
  "current_tier": "T3_live_readonly",
  "dependencies": {
    "apply_role": "kb_apply",
    "apply_script": "scripts/apply_proposal.py",
    "approve_script": "scripts/approve_proposal.py",
    "credential_files": {
      "apply": {
        "present_at_start": true,
        "runtime_location": "ephemeral_or_operator_managed"
      },
      "review": {
        "present_at_start": true,
        "runtime_location": "ephemeral_or_operator_managed"
      }
    },
    "gate_owner_role": "kb_gate_owner",
    "immutable_approval_table": "kb_stage.kb_proposal_approvals",
    "prerequisites_sql": "scripts/kb_apply_prereqs.sql",
    "review_role": "kb_review",
    "reviewer_handle": "m3ta",
    "security_definer_argument_types": {
      "kb_stage.approve_strict_proposal": "uuid, text, jsonb, text, text",
      "kb_stage.assert_approved_proposal": "uuid, text, jsonb, text, uuid, timestamp with time zone, text",
      "kb_stage.finish_approved_proposal": "uuid, text, jsonb, text, uuid, timestamp with time zone, text, text"
    },
    "security_definer_functions": [
      "kb_stage.approve_strict_proposal",
      "kb_stage.assert_approved_proposal",
      "kb_stage.finish_approved_proposal"
    ]
  },
  "downstream_dependency_rollback_refusal": {
    "dependency_refusal": true,
    "dependency_row_preserved": true,
    "owned_rows_preserved": true,
    "proposal_remained_applied": true,
    "returncode": 3
  },
  "external_claim_seed": {
    "clone_rows": [],
    "exact_clone_copy": true,
    "required_ids": [],
    "source_rows": []
  },
  "first_apply": {
    "result": {
      "applied": true,
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "replay_material_sha256": "3583ba36b109a0269c4c495fba325fe419a4776238959cadd49f67b4831520c6",
      "replay_ready": true
    },
    "returncode": 0,
    "stderr": ""
  },
  "fixture_ids": {
    "conflict_claim_id": "3025315d-fca3-55f7-99f3-95d5588fddb4",
    "conflict_proposal_id": "3e80ebda-c58d-5d4a-aaba-c2140371c1f4",
    "conflict_source_id": "4d393879-78d4-59e1-a41a-498c5fa8e1cb",
    "permission_claim_id": "3a5dc7cb-bd20-56a0-8d56-a68acc01c429",
    "permission_source_id": "1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
    "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d"
  },
  "fresh_owned_preflight": {
    "apply_payload_sha256": "89faf1f2fc9481574934de0eefb91cb8056e10784ec0f966c621621ff4f91b02",
    "artifact": "proposal_apply_fresh_preflight",
    "captured_at_utc": "2026-07-15T03:30:09.318963+00:00",
    "fresh_owned_targets": true,
    "preflight_artifact_sha256": "33ae0ebf83cb0d29c0f07e45587b912f7716faa7360ec585c46b65e593723dee",
    "preflight_sha256": "3c4a6b90e6cbb7aa9f93966465f26ada386c2e3bd8326a8bfb23c2efb0c142b8",
    "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
    "proposal_payload_sha256": "3e499f82baa1fa80dba0fdeee7133dfec9c92f111a9cd1aa0b77fe0a3c12c112",
    "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
    "schema": "livingip.proposalApplyFreshPreflight.v1",
    "target_rows_before": {
      "claim_edges": [],
      "claim_evidence": [],
      "claims": [],
      "reasoning_tools": [],
      "sources": []
    }
  },
  "gateway_process_observable": true,
  "generated_at_utc": "2026-07-15T03:30:04.429291+00:00",
  "idempotent_replay": {
    "already_applied_refusal": true,
    "returncode": 1,
    "stderr": "proposal 0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d is already applied (idempotent no-op)"
  },
  "intervening_exact_row_refusal": {
    "intervening_row_preserved": true,
    "proposal_remained_approved": true,
    "returncode": 1,
    "strict_insert_refused": true
  },
  "kb_apply_claim_evidence_update_probe": {
    "after": {
      "claim_id": "3a5dc7cb-bd20-56a0-8d56-a68acc01c429",
      "created_by": null,
      "role": "grounds",
      "source_id": "1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
      "weight": 0.42
    },
    "attempt": {
      "refused": true,
      "returncode": 3,
      "stderr": "ERROR:  permission denied for table claim_evidence",
      "stdout": ""
    },
    "before": {
      "claim_id": "3a5dc7cb-bd20-56a0-8d56-a68acc01c429",
      "created_by": null,
      "role": "grounds",
      "source_id": "1438f592-0378-594a-9b9a-87dfb2a30cc0",
      "weight": 0.42
    },
    "exact_row_unchanged": true
  },
  "kb_apply_proposal_mutation_probes": {
    "after": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "approval_fields": {
      "refused": true,
      "returncode": 3,
      "stderr": "ERROR:  permission denied for table kb_proposals",
      "stdout": ""
    },
    "before": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "exact_row_unchanged": true,
    "immutable_approval_after": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "immutable_approval_before": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "immutable_approval_exactly_unchanged": true,
    "immutable_approval_payload": {
      "refused": true,
      "returncode": 3,
      "stderr": "ERROR:  permission denied for table kb_proposal_approvals",
      "stdout": ""
    },
    "payload": {
      "refused": true,
      "returncode": 3,
      "stderr": "ERROR:  permission denied for table kb_proposals",
      "stdout": ""
    }
  },
  "leftover_clone_count": 0,
  "mutation_between_build_and_execute": {
    "approval_restored_exactly": true,
    "approved_before_mutation": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "build_returncode": 0,
    "built_sql_sha256": "ca785dbaf04dc37ff25b563a42ae2f645780562df3aba1a41b1711b9b83d694f",
    "built_sql_uses_assert_approved_proposal": true,
    "built_sql_uses_finish_approved_proposal": true,
    "canonical_rows_unchanged": true,
    "immutable_approval_after_ledger_mutation": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "immutable_approval_after_stale_execute": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "immutable_approval_before_mutation": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "immutable_approval_never_changed": true,
    "mutated_readback": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        },
        "mutation_after_build": true
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "proposal_after_stale_execute": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        },
        "mutation_after_build": true
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "restored_immutable_approval": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "restored_readback": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "rows_after_stale_execute": {
      "claim_edges": [],
      "claim_evidence": [],
      "claims": [],
      "reasoning_tools": [],
      "sources": []
    },
    "stale_apply_refused": true,
    "stale_execute": {
      "returncode": 3,
      "stderr": "ERROR:  assert_approved_proposal: proposal 0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d is not the exact immutable approved snapshot\nCONTEXT:  PL/pgSQL function kb_stage.assert_approved_proposal(uuid,text,jsonb,text,uuid,timestamp with time zone,text) line 22 at RAISE",
      "stdout": ""
    }
  },
  "outer_isolation": {
    "canonical_table_deltas": {
      "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
      "public.claim_edges": 0,
      "public.claim_evidence": 0,
      "public.claims": 0,
      "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
      "public.sources": 0
    },
    "cleanup_readback": {
      "container_name_query_returncode": 0,
      "container_name_query_stdout": "",
      "container_remove_returncode": 0,
      "label_scoped_orphan_count": 0,
      "label_scoped_query_returncode": 0,
      "label_scoped_query_stdout": "",
      "label_scoped_temporary_container_absent": true,
      "temporary_container_absent": true,
      "temporary_workdir_absent": true,
      "workdir_lexists_after_cleanup": false,
      "workdir_remove_returncode": 0
    },
    "container_isolation": {
      "canary_label": "proposal-apply-lifecycle",
      "instance_label": "working-leo-approve-claim-1281-2032206",
      "lifecycle_labeled": true,
      "network_disabled": true,
      "network_mode": "none",
      "no_docker_volumes": true,
      "volume_mounts": []
    },
    "service_after": {
      "ActiveState": "active",
      "Available": "true",
      "ExecMainStartTimestamp": "Tue 2026-07-14 22:59:43 UTC",
      "MainPID": "347406",
      "NRestarts": "0",
      "SubState": "running"
    },
    "service_before": {
      "ActiveState": "active",
      "Available": "true",
      "ExecMainStartTimestamp": "Tue 2026-07-14 22:59:43 UTC",
      "MainPID": "347406",
      "NRestarts": "0",
      "SubState": "running"
    },
    "service_gate_passes": true,
    "service_observable": true,
    "service_required": true,
    "service_stable": true,
    "source_boundary": {
      "canary_label": "",
      "network_mode": "bridge",
      "source_tier": "live-readonly",
      "tier_enforced": true
    },
    "source_container": "teleo-pg",
    "source_counts_after": {
      "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 29,
      "public.claim_edges": 4916,
      "public.claim_evidence": 4670,
      "public.claims": 1837,
      "public.reasoning_tools": 17,
      "public.sources": 4145
    },
    "source_counts_before": {
      "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 29,
      "public.claim_edges": 4916,
      "public.claim_evidence": 4670,
      "public.claims": 1837,
      "public.reasoning_tools": 17,
      "public.sources": 4145
    },
    "source_counts_unchanged": true,
    "source_database": "teleo"
  },
  "payload_agent_seed": {
    "clone_rows": [],
    "exact_clone_copy": true,
    "required_ids": [],
    "source_rows": []
  },
  "payload_projection": {
    "expected_rows": {
      "claim_edges": [
        {
          "created_by": null,
          "edge_type": "supports",
          "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
          "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
          "weight": 0.75
        }
      ],
      "claim_evidence": [
        {
          "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
          "created_by": null,
          "role": "grounds",
          "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
          "weight": 0.9
        },
        {
          "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
          "created_by": null,
          "role": "illustrates",
          "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
          "weight": 0.8
        }
      ],
      "claims": [
        {
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "created_by": null,
          "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
          "status": "open",
          "superseded_by": null,
          "tags": [
            "working-leo",
            "clone-canary"
          ],
          "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
          "type": "structural"
        },
        {
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "created_by": null,
          "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
          "status": "open",
          "superseded_by": null,
          "tags": [
            "working-leo",
            "row-proof"
          ],
          "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
          "type": "concept"
        }
      ],
      "reasoning_tools": [
        {
          "agent_id": null,
          "category": "verification",
          "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
          "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
          "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
        }
      ],
      "sources": [
        {
          "created_by": null,
          "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
          "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
          "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
          "source_type": "observation",
          "storage_path": null,
          "url": null
        },
        {
          "created_by": null,
          "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
          "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
          "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
          "source_type": "observation",
          "storage_path": null,
          "url": null
        }
      ]
    },
    "expected_table_deltas": {
      "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
      "public.claim_edges": 1,
      "public.claim_evidence": 2,
      "public.claims": 2,
      "public.reasoning_tools": 1,
      "public.sources": 2
    },
    "payload_sha256": "89faf1f2fc9481574934de0eefb91cb8056e10784ec0f966c621621ff4f91b02"
  },
  "post_rollback_worker_apply": {
    "proposal_status": "canceled",
    "returncode": 1,
    "terminal_status_refusal": true
  },
  "post_run_cleanup": {
    "gateway_active_state": "active",
    "gateway_main_pid": "347406",
    "gateway_process_observable": true,
    "gateway_restart_count": "0",
    "gateway_sub_state": "running",
    "leftover_clone_database_count": 0
  },
  "required_tier": "T3_live_readonly",
  "required_tiers": [
    "T2_runtime",
    "T3_live_readonly"
  ],
  "review_transition": {
    "approved_readback": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta",
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "approved"
    },
    "exact_transition": true,
    "immutable_approval_matches_ledger": true,
    "immutable_approval_readback": {
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "review_note": "Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.",
      "reviewed_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00",
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "reviewed_by_db_role": "kb_review",
      "reviewed_by_handle": "m3ta"
    },
    "pending_immutable_approval": null,
    "pending_readback": {
      "applied_at": null,
      "applied_by_agent_id": null,
      "applied_by_handle": null,
      "channel": "clone_canary",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "payload": {
        "apply_payload": {
          "agent_id": null,
          "claims": [
            {
              "confidence": 0.9,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "clone-canary"
              ],
              "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
              "type": "structural"
            },
            {
              "confidence": 0.85,
              "created_by": null,
              "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "status": "open",
              "superseded_by": null,
              "tags": [
                "working-leo",
                "row-proof"
              ],
              "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
              "type": "concept"
            }
          ],
          "contract_version": 2,
          "edges": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "edge_type": "supports",
              "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "weight": 0.75
            }
          ],
          "evidence": [
            {
              "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "grounds",
              "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "weight": 0.9
            },
            {
              "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
              "created_by": null,
              "role": "illustrates",
              "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "weight": 0.8
            }
          ],
          "reasoning_tools": [
            {
              "agent_id": null,
              "category": "verification",
              "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
              "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
              "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
            }
          ],
          "sources": [
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
              "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            },
            {
              "created_by": null,
              "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
              "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
              "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
              "source_type": "observation",
              "storage_path": null,
              "url": null
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "proposal_type": "approve_claim",
      "rationale": "Exercise strict canonical bundle review and apply lifecycle.",
      "review_note": null,
      "reviewed_at": null,
      "reviewed_by_agent_id": null,
      "reviewed_by_handle": null,
      "source_ref": "working-leo:approve-claim-clone-canary",
      "status": "pending_review"
    },
    "review_apply": {
      "returncode": 0,
      "stderr": "",
      "stdout": "{\"id\": \"0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d\", \"proposal_type\": \"approve_claim\", \"review_note\": \"Reviewed exact strict payload inside the disposable clone.\", \"reviewed_at\": \"2026-07-15 03:30:07.092864+00\", \"reviewed_by_agent_id\": \"99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999\", \"reviewed_by_db_role\": \"kb_review\", \"reviewed_by_handle\": \"m3ta\", \"status\": \"approved\"}"
    },
    "review_dry_run": {
      "returncode": 0,
      "stderr": "",
      "uses_approve_strict_proposal": true
    }
  },
  "reviewer_agent_seed": {
    "clone_row": {
      "handle": "m3ta",
      "id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "kind": "human"
    },
    "exact_clone_copy": true,
    "reviewer_handle": "m3ta",
    "source_row": {
      "handle": "m3ta",
      "id": "99999999-9999-9999-9999-999999999999",
      "kind": "human"
    }
  },
  "rollback_plan": {
    "execution_authority": "disposable_clone_admin_only",
    "rollback_sql_sha256": "5b184fc6a65373549b257c3dd40abac91bb90bd4c75b890798fcabc4174dee7b",
    "schema": "livingip.proposalApplyRollback.v2"
  },
  "rollback_replay": {
    "refused": true,
    "returncode": 3,
    "state_unchanged": true,
    "stderr": "ERROR:  proposal rollback: applied ledger does not match apply receipt\nCONTEXT:  PL/pgSQL function inline_code_block line 27 at RAISE"
  },
  "row_readback": {
    "claim_edges": [
      {
        "created_by": null,
        "edge_type": "supports",
        "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
        "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
        "weight": 0.75
      }
    ],
    "claim_evidence": [
      {
        "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
        "created_by": null,
        "role": "grounds",
        "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
        "weight": 0.9
      },
      {
        "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
        "created_by": null,
        "role": "illustrates",
        "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
        "weight": 0.8
      }
    ],
    "claims": [
      {
        "confidence": 0.9,
        "created_by": null,
        "id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
        "status": "open",
        "superseded_by": null,
        "tags": [
          "working-leo",
          "clone-canary"
        ],
        "text": "An approved strict proposal can create exact canonical rows atomically.",
        "type": "structural"
      },
      {
        "confidence": 0.85,
        "created_by": null,
        "id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
        "status": "open",
        "superseded_by": null,
        "tags": [
          "working-leo",
          "row-proof"
        ],
        "text": "Row-level proof is the authority for canonical KB state.",
        "type": "concept"
      }
    ],
    "reasoning_tools": [
      {
        "agent_id": null,
        "category": "verification",
        "description": "Verify approved proposal to canonical graph lifecycle in a disposable clone.",
        "id": "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c",
        "name": "Canonical row proof canary"
      }
    ],
    "sources": [
      {
        "created_by": null,
        "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source B.",
        "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-b",
        "id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
        "source_type": "observation",
        "storage_path": null,
        "url": null
      },
      {
        "created_by": null,
        "excerpt": "Disposable clone lifecycle canary source A.",
        "hash": "approve-claim-canary-4d6107db5d-a",
        "id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd",
        "source_type": "observation",
        "storage_path": null,
        "url": null
      }
    ]
  },
  "runtime_scope": "isolated_postgres_container_from_readonly_live_schema",
  "schema": "working-leo.approve-claim-clone-canary.v3",
  "security_definer_readback": {
    "functions": [
      {
        "argument_types": "uuid, text, jsonb, text, text",
        "expected_role": "kb_review",
        "expected_role_execute": true,
        "function": "kb_stage.approve_strict_proposal",
        "identity_arguments": "p_proposal_id uuid, p_expected_proposal_type text, p_expected_payload jsonb, p_expected_reviewed_by_handle text, p_review_note text",
        "other_runtime_role_execute": false,
        "owner": "kb_gate_owner",
        "present": true,
        "public_execute": false,
        "security_definer": true
      },
      {
        "argument_types": "uuid, text, jsonb, text, uuid, timestamp with time zone, text",
        "expected_role": "kb_apply",
        "expected_role_execute": true,
        "function": "kb_stage.assert_approved_proposal",
        "identity_arguments": "p_proposal_id uuid, p_proposal_type text, p_payload jsonb, p_reviewed_by_handle text, p_reviewed_by_agent_id uuid, p_reviewed_at timestamp with time zone, p_review_note text",
        "other_runtime_role_execute": false,
        "owner": "kb_gate_owner",
        "present": true,
        "public_execute": false,
        "security_definer": true
      },
      {
        "argument_types": "uuid, text, jsonb, text, uuid, timestamp with time zone, text, text",
        "expected_role": "kb_apply",
        "expected_role_execute": true,
        "function": "kb_stage.finish_approved_proposal",
        "identity_arguments": "p_proposal_id uuid, p_proposal_type text, p_payload jsonb, p_reviewed_by_handle text, p_reviewed_by_agent_id uuid, p_reviewed_at timestamp with time zone, p_review_note text, p_applied_by_handle text",
        "other_runtime_role_execute": false,
        "owner": "kb_gate_owner",
        "present": true,
        "public_execute": false,
        "security_definer": true
      }
    ],
    "login_role_owned_objects": [],
    "protected_role_memberships": [],
    "role_privileges": {
      "kb_apply_approval_snapshot_select": false,
      "kb_apply_approval_snapshot_update": false,
      "kb_apply_claim_evidence_insert": true,
      "kb_apply_claim_evidence_update": false,
      "kb_apply_proposal_select": true,
      "kb_apply_proposal_update": false,
      "kb_review_approval_snapshot_select": false,
      "kb_review_approval_snapshot_update": false,
      "kb_review_proposal_select": true,
      "kb_review_proposal_update": false
    },
    "unexpected_overloads": []
  },
  "service_after": {
    "ActiveState": "active",
    "ExecMainStartTimestamp": "Tue 2026-07-14 22:59:43 UTC",
    "MainPID": "347406",
    "NRestarts": "0",
    "SubState": "running",
    "available": true,
    "returncode": 0
  },
  "service_before": {
    "ActiveState": "active",
    "ExecMainStartTimestamp": "Tue 2026-07-14 22:59:43 UTC",
    "MainPID": "347406",
    "NRestarts": "0",
    "SubState": "running",
    "available": true,
    "returncode": 0
  },
  "service_restarted": false,
  "source_binding": {
    "files": [
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/apply_proposal.py",
        "sha256": "9b95601753203c167190c4a33a05bd36fd68178cfc4cbd76be7c0c69e103b52f",
        "size_bytes": 50074
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/approve_proposal.py",
        "sha256": "e991498264bd0f49755dfef809212fa7151a668ce479b100d830e447775a9fe0",
        "size_bytes": 7323
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/finalize_approve_claim_isolated_canary.py",
        "sha256": "d5dbd250a9fc28a22ab0880a57c330b3c95119b95d96c5df95cbaf49648bccb5",
        "size_bytes": 10684
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/kb_apply_prereqs.sql",
        "sha256": "bdf8c5da05eed10665b05ad1e331e3c9c8d72464c59889a3cf8f34ab23822faa",
        "size_bytes": 42602
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/proposal_apply_lifecycle.py",
        "sha256": "1122cc3a02a93ca1a41d6088a4852b3f4f47efa5c7a373c19c46605cff4853e6",
        "size_bytes": 86177
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/run_approve_claim_clone_canary.py",
        "sha256": "66f176712c9aa3d3dc8f18b6313b8ca393f2e93c0acce2b4d2344d97905c55c7",
        "size_bytes": 94909
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/run_approve_claim_isolated_container_canary.sh",
        "sha256": "ed81a8f8c05d516809bb54c80d82786ed941dc1cf87150f25addc935685c72bb",
        "size_bytes": 9239
      }
    ],
    "independent_post_cleanup_verification": {
      "all_match": true,
      "files": [
        {
          "actual_sha256": "9b95601753203c167190c4a33a05bd36fd68178cfc4cbd76be7c0c69e103b52f",
          "expected_sha256": "9b95601753203c167190c4a33a05bd36fd68178cfc4cbd76be7c0c69e103b52f",
          "matches": true,
          "repo_relative_path": "scripts/apply_proposal.py",
          "size_bytes": 50074
        },
        {
          "actual_sha256": "e991498264bd0f49755dfef809212fa7151a668ce479b100d830e447775a9fe0",
          "expected_sha256": "e991498264bd0f49755dfef809212fa7151a668ce479b100d830e447775a9fe0",
          "matches": true,
          "repo_relative_path": "scripts/approve_proposal.py",
          "size_bytes": 7323
        },
        {
          "actual_sha256": "d5dbd250a9fc28a22ab0880a57c330b3c95119b95d96c5df95cbaf49648bccb5",
          "expected_sha256": "d5dbd250a9fc28a22ab0880a57c330b3c95119b95d96c5df95cbaf49648bccb5",
          "matches": true,
          "repo_relative_path": "scripts/finalize_approve_claim_isolated_canary.py",
          "size_bytes": 10684
        },
        {
          "actual_sha256": "bdf8c5da05eed10665b05ad1e331e3c9c8d72464c59889a3cf8f34ab23822faa",
          "expected_sha256": "bdf8c5da05eed10665b05ad1e331e3c9c8d72464c59889a3cf8f34ab23822faa",
          "matches": true,
          "repo_relative_path": "scripts/kb_apply_prereqs.sql",
          "size_bytes": 42602
        },
        {
          "actual_sha256": "1122cc3a02a93ca1a41d6088a4852b3f4f47efa5c7a373c19c46605cff4853e6",
          "expected_sha256": "1122cc3a02a93ca1a41d6088a4852b3f4f47efa5c7a373c19c46605cff4853e6",
          "matches": true,
          "repo_relative_path": "scripts/proposal_apply_lifecycle.py",
          "size_bytes": 86177
        },
        {
          "actual_sha256": "66f176712c9aa3d3dc8f18b6313b8ca393f2e93c0acce2b4d2344d97905c55c7",
          "expected_sha256": "66f176712c9aa3d3dc8f18b6313b8ca393f2e93c0acce2b4d2344d97905c55c7",
          "matches": true,
          "repo_relative_path": "scripts/run_approve_claim_clone_canary.py",
          "size_bytes": 94909
        },
        {
          "actual_sha256": "ed81a8f8c05d516809bb54c80d82786ed941dc1cf87150f25addc935685c72bb",
          "expected_sha256": "ed81a8f8c05d516809bb54c80d82786ed941dc1cf87150f25addc935685c72bb",
          "matches": true,
          "repo_relative_path": "scripts/run_approve_claim_isolated_container_canary.sh",
          "size_bytes": 9239
        }
      ]
    },
    "post_run_files": [
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/apply_proposal.py",
        "sha256": "9b95601753203c167190c4a33a05bd36fd68178cfc4cbd76be7c0c69e103b52f",
        "size_bytes": 50074
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/approve_proposal.py",
        "sha256": "e991498264bd0f49755dfef809212fa7151a668ce479b100d830e447775a9fe0",
        "size_bytes": 7323
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/finalize_approve_claim_isolated_canary.py",
        "sha256": "d5dbd250a9fc28a22ab0880a57c330b3c95119b95d96c5df95cbaf49648bccb5",
        "size_bytes": 10684
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/kb_apply_prereqs.sql",
        "sha256": "bdf8c5da05eed10665b05ad1e331e3c9c8d72464c59889a3cf8f34ab23822faa",
        "size_bytes": 42602
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/proposal_apply_lifecycle.py",
        "sha256": "1122cc3a02a93ca1a41d6088a4852b3f4f47efa5c7a373c19c46605cff4853e6",
        "size_bytes": 86177
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/run_approve_claim_clone_canary.py",
        "sha256": "66f176712c9aa3d3dc8f18b6313b8ca393f2e93c0acce2b4d2344d97905c55c7",
        "size_bytes": 94909
      },
      {
        "repo_relative_path": "scripts/run_approve_claim_isolated_container_canary.sh",
        "sha256": "ed81a8f8c05d516809bb54c80d82786ed941dc1cf87150f25addc935685c72bb",
        "size_bytes": 9239
      }
    ],
    "unchanged_during_run": true
  },
  "source_cluster_roles_after": [
    {
      "rolbypassrls": false,
      "rolcanlogin": true,
      "rolconnlimit": -1,
      "rolcreatedb": false,
      "rolcreaterole": false,
      "rolinherit": false,
      "rolname": "kb_apply",
      "rolreplication": false,
      "rolsuper": false,
      "rolvaliduntil": null
    },
    {
      "rolbypassrls": false,
      "rolcanlogin": false,
      "rolconnlimit": -1,
      "rolcreatedb": false,
      "rolcreaterole": false,
      "rolinherit": false,
      "rolname": "kb_gate_owner",
      "rolreplication": false,
      "rolsuper": false,
      "rolvaliduntil": null
    },
    {
      "rolbypassrls": false,
      "rolcanlogin": true,
      "rolconnlimit": -1,
      "rolcreatedb": false,
      "rolcreaterole": false,
      "rolinherit": false,
      "rolname": "kb_review",
      "rolreplication": false,
      "rolsuper": false,
      "rolvaliduntil": null
    }
  ],
  "source_cluster_roles_before": [
    {
      "rolbypassrls": false,
      "rolcanlogin": true,
      "rolconnlimit": -1,
      "rolcreatedb": false,
      "rolcreaterole": false,
      "rolinherit": false,
      "rolname": "kb_apply",
      "rolreplication": false,
      "rolsuper": false,
      "rolvaliduntil": null
    },
    {
      "rolbypassrls": false,
      "rolcanlogin": false,
      "rolconnlimit": -1,
      "rolcreatedb": false,
      "rolcreaterole": false,
      "rolinherit": false,
      "rolname": "kb_gate_owner",
      "rolreplication": false,
      "rolsuper": false,
      "rolvaliduntil": null
    },
    {
      "rolbypassrls": false,
      "rolcanlogin": true,
      "rolconnlimit": -1,
      "rolcreatedb": false,
      "rolcreaterole": false,
      "rolinherit": false,
      "rolname": "kb_review",
      "rolreplication": false,
      "rolsuper": false,
      "rolvaliduntil": null
    }
  ],
  "source_counts_after": {
    "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
    "public.claim_edges": 0,
    "public.claim_evidence": 0,
    "public.claims": 1837,
    "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
    "public.sources": 0
  },
  "source_counts_before": {
    "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
    "public.claim_edges": 0,
    "public.claim_evidence": 0,
    "public.claims": 1837,
    "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
    "public.sources": 0
  },
  "source_counts_observed_unchanged": true,
  "source_database": "teleo",
  "source_database_mutated": false,
  "source_table_deltas": {
    "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
    "public.claim_edges": 0,
    "public.claim_evidence": 0,
    "public.claims": 0,
    "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
    "public.sources": 0
  },
  "source_target_rows_after": {
    "claim_edges": [],
    "claim_evidence": [],
    "claims": [],
    "reasoning_tools": [],
    "sources": []
  },
  "source_target_rows_before": {
    "claim_edges": [],
    "claim_evidence": [],
    "claims": [],
    "reasoning_tools": [],
    "sources": []
  },
  "status": "pass",
  "strict_receipt": {
    "canonical_row_keys": {
      "actual": {
        "public.claim_edges": [
          {
            "edge_type": "supports",
            "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
            "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95"
          }
        ],
        "public.claim_evidence": [
          {
            "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
            "role": "grounds",
            "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd"
          },
          {
            "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
            "role": "illustrates",
            "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf"
          }
        ],
        "public.claims": [
          "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
          "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95"
        ],
        "public.reasoning_tools": [
          "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c"
        ],
        "public.sources": [
          "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
          "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd"
        ]
      },
      "expected": {
        "public.claim_edges": [
          {
            "edge_type": "supports",
            "from_claim": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
            "to_claim": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95"
          }
        ],
        "public.claim_evidence": [
          {
            "claim_id": "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
            "role": "grounds",
            "source_id": "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd"
          },
          {
            "claim_id": "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95",
            "role": "illustrates",
            "source_id": "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf"
          }
        ],
        "public.claims": [
          "32cc5b57-0d89-58aa-9cc1-f9e0c63947fb",
          "4d8f5ef5-d1a3-5043-a9e8-fdc202c10d95"
        ],
        "public.reasoning_tools": [
          "41b58d96-37f6-526c-b021-58f1dbcfdb6c"
        ],
        "public.sources": [
          "7a2198b6-16b2-52c6-a641-7ad59826e5bf",
          "bf697d93-8b77-5e2b-a6c0-0825e5ba76fd"
        ]
      }
    },
    "checks": {
      "before_after_counts_present": true,
      "canonical_row_keys_exact": true,
      "canonical_rows_exact": true,
      "clone_database_removed": true,
      "conflict_transaction_rolled_back": true,
      "proposal_applied_at_present": true,
      "proposal_id_exact": true,
      "proposal_status_applied": true,
      "source_database_unchanged": true,
      "table_deltas_exact": true
    },
    "pass": true,
    "proposal": {
      "applied_at": "2026-07-15 03:30:10.578016+00",
      "applied_by_handle": "kb-apply",
      "id": "0b5cfd03-8c1f-509a-b1e1-a05e45164d8d",
      "status": "applied"
    },
    "rollback_cleanup": {
      "clone_database_removed": true,
      "conflict_transaction_rolled_back": true,
      "leftover_clone_database_count": 0,
      "source_database_unchanged": true
    },
    "row_counts": {
      "actual_deltas": {
        "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
        "public.claim_edges": 1,
        "public.claim_evidence": 2,
        "public.claims": 2,
        "public.reasoning_tools": 1,
        "public.sources": 2
      },
      "after_apply": {
        "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 1,
        "public.claim_edges": 1,
        "public.claim_evidence": 3,
        "public.claims": 3,
        "public.reasoning_tools": 1,
        "public.sources": 3
      },
      "before_apply": {
        "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 1,
        "public.claim_edges": 0,
        "public.claim_evidence": 1,
        "public.claims": 1,
        "public.reasoning_tools": 0,
        "public.sources": 1
      },
      "expected_deltas": {
        "kb_stage.kb_proposals": 0,
        "public.claim_edges": 1,
        "public.claim_evidence": 2,
        "public.claims": 2,
        "public.reasoning_tools": 1,
        "public.sources": 2
      }
    },
    "schema": "working-leo.approved-change-strict-receipt.v1"
  },
  "target_rows_before_apply": {
    "claim_edges": [],
    "claim_evidence": [],
    "claims": [],
    "reasoning_tools": [],
    "sources": []
  },
  "telegram_messages_sent": false,
  "unrelated_fingerprint_before_apply": {
    "kb_stage.kb_proposal_approvals": {
      "content_md5": "d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e",
      "row_count": 0
    },
    "kb_stage.kb_proposals": {
      "content_md5": "d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e",
      "row_count": 0
    },
    "public.agents": {
      "content_md5": "d67081359e7ec2fa2101b26f3e1b3f75",
      "row_count": 2
    },
    "public.claim_edges": {
      "content_md5": "d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e",
      "row_count": 0
    },
    "public.claim_evidence": {
      "content_md5": "da01cd47b5562650406f21a18aaea9b6",
      "row_count": 1
    },
    "public.claims": {
      "content_md5": "01ad0f2d690600be6a1988899c3e743e",
      "row_count": 1
    },
    "public.reasoning_tools": {
      "content_md5": "d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e",
      "row_count": 0
    },
    "public.sources": {
      "content_md5": "18a42c193671894196c47d58da8da024",
      "row_count": 1
    }
  }
}