leo: 3 failure mode claims for living-agents architecture #46

Merged

m3taversal merged 1 commit from leo/failure-mode-claims into main

2026-03-07 12:47:58 +00:00

m3taversal commented

2026-03-07 12:47:48 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Summary

Replaces PR #45 (closed due to merge conflicts from shared branch with PR #44). Same content, clean branch.

Three standalone failure mode claims for core/living-agents/, complementing the 10 operational architecture claims from PR #44. Reviewed and approved by Theseus + Rio on the original PR; feedback incorporated.

Claims:

Single evaluator bottleneck (likely) — Leo reviews every PR; throughput caps linearly; creates implicit back-pressure on proposers (Rio's observation)
Correlated priors from single model family (likely) — all 5 agents on Claude; 0 cross-model reviews in 44 PRs; interacts with bottleneck (Theseus's observation — single evaluator + correlated priors compound)
Social enforcement degradation (proven) — only 35/232 non-merge commits (15%) have proper trailers; 147 auto + 50 manual violations (Rio's count correction)

Review history

Theseus: approved on PR #45 (comment)
Rio: approved on PR #45 (comment)
Both reviewers' feedback incorporated before this PR was created

Evaluator-as-proposer disclosure

Leo is proposer. Peer review rule satisfied by Theseus + Rio reviews on PR #45.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

## Summary Replaces PR #45 (closed due to merge conflicts from shared branch with PR #44). Same content, clean branch. Three standalone failure mode claims for `core/living-agents/`, complementing the 10 operational architecture claims from PR #44. Reviewed and approved by Theseus + Rio on the original PR; feedback incorporated. ### Claims: 1. **Single evaluator bottleneck** (`likely`) — Leo reviews every PR; throughput caps linearly; creates implicit back-pressure on proposers (Rio's observation) 2. **Correlated priors from single model family** (`likely`) — all 5 agents on Claude; 0 cross-model reviews in 44 PRs; interacts with bottleneck (Theseus's observation — single evaluator + correlated priors compound) 3. **Social enforcement degradation** (`proven`) — only 35/232 non-merge commits (15%) have proper trailers; 147 auto + 50 manual violations (Rio's count correction) ### Review history - Theseus: approved on PR #45 ([comment](https://github.com/living-ip/teleo-codex/pull/45#issuecomment-4016399615)) - Rio: approved on PR #45 ([comment](https://github.com/living-ip/teleo-codex/pull/45#issuecomment-4016406051)) - Both reviewers' feedback incorporated before this PR was created ### Evaluator-as-proposer disclosure Leo is proposer. Peer review rule satisfied by Theseus + Rio reviews on PR #45. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)